St Louis Near Me Directory
📍 Is your business already listed? Claim your free listing · badge, QR code & more.Claim it Free →
Home › Blog

Gelato vs. Ice Cream? The Gooey Butter Scoop Is Custard

Revised October 26, 2026

Gelato vs. Ice Cream? The Gooey Butter Scoop Is Custard
Quick answer

Is gelato basically just ice cream?

No. Ice cream must contain at least 10 percent milkfat under federal rules, and gelato is built differently. Gelato di Riso on The Hill says its gelato holds less air than American ice cream, making it more velvety and rich in flavor, and its Dolce gelatos are made with milk instead of high-fat cream. Denser, softer, and the flavor hits faster.

Keep reading ↓

Cream cheese, butter, a crumble of crust, all of it cold and slowly going soft on your tongue. The gooey butter cake scoop at Clementine’s in Lafayette Square tastes like the pastry, and the company says it is the most popular flavor at that shop. Now read its ingredient list. The base is not plain ice cream mix. It is a custard ice cream mix, with egg yolks.

So the scoop most people would call ice cream is quietly closer to the custard on Chippewa than to anything in a gelato case. And that one label is the easiest way to understand the whole gelato-versus-ice-cream question, because the difference is not magic or marketing. It is what goes into the base: milk, cream, or cream plus yolk.

Three local makers publish it. Gelato di Riso on The Hill says its Dolce gelatos are made with milk, instead of high-fat cream. Clementine’s standard ice cream mix starts with cream. And the frozen-custard concrete, the specialty of Ted Drewes on Chippewa, starts from a base with its own federal line for egg yolk. You can taste all three in one evening, in that order, for the price of three cups. Here is how.

Is gelato basically just ice cream?

No. Ice cream has a legal floor in this country: under the federal standard, it must contain not less than 10 percent milkfat and weigh not less than 4.5 pounds to the gallon. What the good gelato shops do is spelled out by the shops themselves.

Gelato di Riso puts it plainly on its own site: its Italian gelato is made fresh every day, and it contains less air than American ice cream, making it more velvety in texture and rich in flavor. Less air is the part you feel first. The scoop sits heavier in the cup. It does not squeak against your teeth the way a hard-frozen ball of ice cream does. It slumps, and the flavor arrives all at once instead of after the cold wears off.

Spoon one: milk, on The Hill

Gelato di Riso says its home on The Hill is where it makes all of its gelato, and it sells it there and at its second shop in downtown Kirkwood. The menu splits the case in two. Milk-based flavors run from Amaretto and Bacio to Stracciatella and Tiramisu. Water-based fruit flavors, Blood Orange, Lemon, Mango, Pink Grapefruit and more, carry no milk at all, which is why a lemon there can taste sharp enough to make your jaw tingle.

Two practical notes from the shop’s own menu. Flavors change daily, and it tells you to call the store for what is in the case, so do not drive across town for one flavor without calling. And if the evening is cool, order the affogato, espresso poured over your choice of gelato, and watch the hot coffee carve a little brown canyon through the scoop.

Spoon two: cream, in Lafayette Square

Clementine’s publishes its ingredients, and the standard ice cream mix starts with cream, milk, skim milk, sugar and nonfat dry milk. That is the richer, rounder, coat-your-mouth feeling of American ice cream, the kind that leaves a film on the spoon. The company calls itself a maker of small-batch flavors, including Naughty, alcohol-infused ones, and non-dairy options.

At its Lafayette Square shop, the company says its most popular flavor is gooey butter cake, and that owner Tamara Keefe was the first to turn the classic St. Louis breakfast pastry into a frozen treat. Look at that flavor’s ingredient list and the base changes: a custard ice cream mix with egg yolks, then cream cheese, butter and crust folded in. So the most St. Louis scoop in that case is quietly closer to custard than to gelato.

Spoon three: cream and yolk, on Chippewa

Frozen custard has a legal line of its own. The same federal rule says frozen custard shall contain 1.4 percent egg yolk solids by weight of the finished food, and ordinary ice cream contains less than that. The yolk is what makes custard eat silky and dense, and it is why a St. Louis concrete can hang upside down over a parking lot without falling out of the cup.

According to the State Historical Society of Missouri’s Missouri Encyclopedia, Ted Drewes opened its stand at what is now 6726 Chippewa Street in 1941, tapping the crowds on Route 66. In 1959, a neighborhood teen kept demanding thicker malts, and Drewes Jr., managing the Chippewa stand, tinkered until he had a malt that could be held upside-down without spilling. He called it a concrete. Stand in that line on a warm night and you will hear the cup get flipped before you see it.

Gelato in a shop case beside a cup of St. Louis frozen custard

What to order at each stop

At Gelato di Riso, the cup sizes tell you how many flavors you get, not just how much: a Piccolo holds 1-2 flavors, a Medio 1-3 and a Grande 1-4, and the waffle cones take 1-2. That makes the Medio the smart order for a comparison night, one milk-based flavor and one fruit flavor side by side, so you can feel the cream-free richness against the clean, cold bite of the fruit. If someone in your group skips sugar, the Hill shop lists sugar-free chocolate and raspberry, and only that location carries them. Pints and quarts go home with you.

At Clementine’s, the gooey butter cake scoop is the obvious local order, and a good test of the custard question, since its own ingredient list puts egg yolks in the base. If you fall for a flavor, the company ships pints nationwide in the continental U.S. It also closes on Thanksgiving Day and Christmas Day, which is worth knowing before you promise the cousins a holiday scoop.

At the custard window on Chippewa, order a concrete and watch the hand-off. It is served upside down to prove the point. That is the whole show, and it comes with the order.

How to run the three-spoon test in one evening

Pick one flavor you can find in all three styles, vanilla or chocolate works, and taste them in the order milk, cream, custard. Going lightest to richest keeps the first spoon from getting buried. Take a sip of water between stops. Let each spoonful sit on your tongue for a second before you swallow, and pay attention to two things: how fast the flavor shows up, and what is left in your mouth afterward.

The gelato tastes like the ingredient. The ice cream tastes like the ingredient wrapped in cream. The custard tastes like a dessert that happens to contain the ingredient. None of them loses. They just answer different cravings, and once you have tasted them in a row you will know which one you were actually craving the next time somebody in the back seat says the word.

One house rule makes it fair: call Gelato di Riso ahead about the flavor list, since it changes daily, and check each shop’s hours on its own site before you go.

Wildly off topic: that slow drip under the kitchen sink is not going to fix itself, so find a St. Louis plumber before the cabinet floor goes soft.

Which is healthier, gelato or regular ice cream?

Neither is health food, and the honest answer depends on the shop. Ice cream carries a legal minimum of 10 percent milkfat. A gelato made with milk instead of high-fat cream, the way Gelato di Riso describes its Dolce flavors, is usually the lower-fat spoonful. A water-based fruit gelato drops the dairy entirely.

The catch is density. Less air means more actual dessert in the same size cup, so a small gelato is not automatically the lighter choice. If you are managing blood sugar, a dairy allergy or a doctor’s orders, ask to see the nutrition or ingredient information. Clementine’s posts ingredient lists flavor by flavor, which is exactly the kind of thing worth reading before you order.

Where frozen custard fits in this town

The Missouri Encyclopedia lists gooey butter cake and frozen-custard concretes among the city’s signature sweets, next to toasted ravioli and Provel pizza on the savory side. Custard is the default summer stop here, a walk-up window and a line in the parking lot, with the line being half the point. It is where a lot of teams end up after a game, and where a lot of kids celebrate their first meet. If that is your household, our guide on signing your kid up for gymnastics in St. Louis covers the part that happens before the custard.

Gelato is the sit-down cousin, a cafe chair, an espresso, a long slow cup. Ice cream sits in between. Knowing that, you can pick the place by the night you want to have, not just the dessert.

Settle it with your own spoon this week. Browse ice cream and gelato shops across the St. Louis metro on St Louis Near Me Directory, pick a gelateria, a creamery and a custard stand, and taste them in that order.

If you run the gelato case, the scoop shop or the custard window people argue about, they are deciding where to go tonight from their phones. A Gold listing on St Louis Near Me Directory puts your flavors, photos and hours in front of them and helps you get more customers in the weeks that make your year. See what Gold includes or list your shop.

Frequently asked questions

What is so special about gelato ice cream?

Less air. Gelato di Riso says its gelato contains less air than American ice cream, making it more velvety in texture and rich in flavor. The scoop is denser, softer and quicker to taste, especially in fruit flavors made with water instead of milk.

Is gelato healthier than ice cream?

Often lower in fat, not always lighter overall. Ice cream must contain at least 10 percent milkfat under federal rules, while a gelato made with milk instead of high-fat cream usually carries less. Gelato is denser, though, so the same size cup holds more dessert. Read the shop’s ingredient or nutrition information if it matters to you.

Why do people prefer gelato over ice cream?

Texture and flavor. Less air makes it velvety rather than fluffy, and less fat coating your tongue lets fruit and nut flavors come through sharper. Plenty of people prefer ice cream for the opposite reason: it is richer and creamier, and it holds up better in a cone on a hot night.

Is gelato more expensive than ice cream?

Prices vary shop to shop, so compare at the counter. When a cup does cost more, part of the reason is the air: a denser product means fewer cups from the same batch, and small batches made fresh daily take more hands than a tub from the freezer aisle.

Does gelato go in the freezer or refrigerator?

The freezer. In the refrigerator it melts and the texture is ruined when it refreezes. A home freezer runs colder than a gelato case, so a pint from Gelato di Riso’s to-go menu will firm up at home. Let it sit on the counter a few minutes before you scoop.

Where is the best place to get gelato?

The shop that makes it on site, in small batches, from a list that changes. Ask at the counter whether they make it there. In St. Louis, Gelato di Riso says it makes all of its gelato at its home on The Hill and changes flavors daily, and it sells it there and in downtown Kirkwood.

Who has the best ice cream in St. Louis?

It depends which of the three you are craving. For velvety Italian gelato, go to a shop that makes it daily. For rich, cream-first ice cream with local flavors, try a small-batch creamery like Clementine’s. For custard, the concrete on Chippewa is the one people line up for.

What is the most famous custard in St. Louis?

Ted Drewes. The Missouri Encyclopedia says its Chippewa stand opened in 1941 on Route 66. In 1959 Drewes Jr. tinkered there until he had a malt that could be held upside-down without spilling, and he called it a concrete.

What is a signature St. Louis dessert?

Gooey butter cake and the frozen custard concrete. You can even get the first one frozen: Clementine’s says gooey butter cake is the most popular flavor at its Lafayette Square shop, built on a custard ice cream mix with egg yolks.

St Louis Near Me Directory Logo
About the Author: The St Louis Near Me Directory Team
Written by a dedicated team of St. Louis locals who live, work, and play right here in the St. Louis metro. Founder Lane Forman and team are committed to building the region’s most trusted directory by verifying listings and connecting local businesses with loyal customers across Missouri and Illinois.
Follow us:
Facebook LinkedIn X Pinterest YouTube Instagram TikTok Threads
St Louis Near Me Directory on Patch
Refuse to be invisible.
Does AI cite your expertise?
Run Your Free AI Audit
No credit card. No obligation.
Business idea? Does your town need it?
When you win, we all win.