St Louis Near Me Directory
📍 Is your business already listed? Claim your free listing · badge, QR code & more.Claim it Free →
Home › Blog

How to Pick a Steakhouse in St. Louis

Revised November 4, 2026

How to Pick a Steakhouse in St. Louis
Quick answer

What are the signs of a good quality steak house?

A good steakhouse names its beef grade, says how the beef is aged, and tells you what each temperature means. Kreis’ in Frontenac prints all three: USDA Prime, aged in house, and a doneness chart that ends “Not responsible for well done steaks.” Check the grade, ask about the aging, and see what comes with the steak before you book.

Keep reading ↓

Fat hits a hot broiler and spits. That sound starts every steak dinner in this town, and at Kreis’ on South Lindbergh the end of the story is already printed on the menu, at the bottom of a five-line doneness chart: “Not responsible for well done steaks.”

Read that line twice. A room that has served steak since the Kreis family opened it as a roadhouse in 1948 is telling you, in writing, exactly where its patience ends. That is the whole trick to picking a St. Louis steakhouse. The good ones put their rules on the page. You just have to read the page before you book, not after the check lands.

Here is what to read for, in order, using two menus that are live right now: Kreis’ in Frontenac and Citizen Kane’s, a family owned and operated steakhouse in a Victorian house.

What are the signs of a good quality steak house?

A good steakhouse names its grade, says how its beef is aged, and tells you what each temperature means. Kreis’ does all three in print: its menu describes its beef as “USDA Prime Midwestern corn-fed Black Angus, aged in house,” and its chart spells out that medium rare is “Red or very pink on the inside.” A menu that commits to that much is a kitchen that expects to be checked.

The grade is the easiest tell, because it is a federal word, not a marketing one. USDA’s Agricultural Marketing Service says Prime beef “is produced from young, well-fed beef cattle” with “at least slightly abundant marbling” and “is generally sold in upscale restaurants,” while Choice “is high quality, but has less marbling than Prime.” Those white threads of fat are what melt on the broiler and make a strip taste like butter at the edges. A menu that says only “hand-cut” has promised you nothing you can check.

The five-minute menu check, before you call for a table

First, find the grade next to the steak. Kreis’ splits its own menu down the middle: both New York strips are Prime, while the ribeye and the prime rib are labeled Certified Angus Beef. Same page, two different promises. If you are paying for Prime, make sure the cut you want is the one that carries the word.

Second, look for the aging. “Aged in house” means the restaurant holds the beef itself before it ever hits the grill. If the menu is silent, ask the server how long and where. A confident kitchen answers in one sentence.

Third, find out what comes with the steak. This is the line that moves your bill the most, and these two menus show why. At Citizen Kane’s, every entree includes “your choice of any side dish, plus Soup du Jour made fresh daily, Or Kane’s Rosebud Salad.” At Kreis’, the steak comes with a side, but salads are their own line, from an $8 house salad to an $11 iceberg wedge.

Fourth, read the fine print at the bottom. Kreis’ asks “Please no splitting of entrees,” reserves the right to add a 20% gratuity for parties of 8 or more, and does no separate checks for a table that size. Better to know that before you invite the whole office.

Fifth, look for the toasted ravioli. Half joking. Both menus carry it, Kreis’ calling it “A St. Louis classic” and Citizen Kane’s “A St. Louis tradition.” A steakhouse that keeps toasted ravioli on the same page as the shrimp cocktail is a local room, not a franchise wearing a local name.

The $46 strip that costs more than the $52.95 one

Put the two menus side by side and the cheaper steak stops being cheaper. Kreis’ lists a 10 oz Prime New York strip at $46 with one side. Add its $9 Caesar salad and the strip, side and salad come to $55. Citizen Kane’s lists its New York strip at $52.95, and the side plus the soup or the Rosebud salad are already in that price.

That is not a knock on either room. Kreis’ strip is the one stamped Prime. It is a reminder that the steak line is never the dinner. Count what your table will actually order, add a drink, tax and tip, and then compare. The strip that looked cheaper on the page now costs more, before anyone opens the wine list.

The small upcharges add up the same way. At Kreis’, a béarnaise or hollandaise is $4, the brandy wild mushroom sauce $6, and asparagus carries a surcharge as your included side. At Kane’s, a béarnaise or brandy peppercorn is $3.95. None of it is hidden. All of it is printed. Most people just never scroll that far. Do it with the menu open on your phone and a pencil, and you will walk in knowing your number, which is a much better feeling than doing math under the table while the server waits with the check folder.

What is the average cost per person at a steakhouse?

There is no honest single number, because menu structure swings it so far. Use the real St. Louis figures above as your yardstick: a strip, a side and a salad come to $55 at Kreis’ and $52.95 at Citizen Kane’s, before drinks, tax and tip. Order the 8 oz filet mignon at Kreis’ and the entree alone is $54; the 20 oz filet is $120.

The cheapest good steak night at Kreis’ is printed right on the home page. The Sunday night special is three courses for $55 per guest: a Caesar or house salad, a 12 oz Queen Cut of prime rib with au jus, creamy horseradish and a side, then amaretto cheesecake or apple strudel. It is dine-in only, internet only, you must mention it when you order, and it does not run on Easter, Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, Christmas Eve or New Year’s Eve.

At the other end of the same menu sits the 64 oz bone-in Extra Cut of prime rib at $145, with a flat house rule beside it: “No Splitting of Extra Cut.” The 32 oz King Cut at $82 gets the same rule. Somebody, at some point, tried. The menu remembers.

The cheapest great steak in town may be the one you sear at home - is a St. Louis butcher cheaper than the grocery store?

How do you read the room before you book?

The building tells you the night. Citizen Kane’s sits in “a classic turn of the century Victorian home” and has served dinner there since 1993. That is a birthday-for-your-father kind of room. Citizen Kane’s steak seasoning is sold at Straubs, Dierbergs and Schnucks, so plenty of St. Louis home grills already taste a little like that dining room. Kreis’ history page describes “the ‘New York Style’ waiters” and a “relaxing country club atmosphere” that the Tompras family kept when they bought it in 1983. It also rents out a Private Dining Room with facilities for up to 75 guests, which is the answer when the rehearsal dinner outgrows a long table.

Say what the night is when you call. Anniversary, birthday, first client dinner: the host writes it down, and it changes which table you get. Both rooms recommend reservations on their own sites. If the evening needs flowers on the table, order them earlier in the day from one of the St. Louis florists on our directory. And if dinner comes before a show, our guide to live theater and performing arts in St. Louis helps you line the two up.

What is the dress code for a steak house?

Kreis’ posts a Business Casual Dress Code and spells out exactly what that means. No athletic wear, sweatpants, cut-off shorts or exposed undergarments. “Mens shirts must have sleeves.” Take off the ball cap or beanie when you walk in. And one rule you will not find on many menus: management may delay seating “due to strong smoke odors.” Skip the cigar on the drive over. When in doubt anywhere else, call; a host will tell you straight in ten seconds.

A dry-aged ribeye and shared sides on a dark steakhouse table in the St. Louis area

What if you are not a steak person?

Order the seafood and skip the apology. Kreis’ runs a full seafood list, from a $28 Icelandic cod with capers and lemon butter to $62 broiled sea scallops, and the German side of its history still shows in a $34 Vienna schnitzel and German potato pancakes with applesauce. Kreis’ even prints a $20 vegetable platter: broccoli, green beans, mushrooms, creamed spinach and your choice of potato. At Citizen Kane’s, the charbroiled Norwegian salmon comes topped with béarnaise and a grilled jumbo shrimp.

If you like your steak well done, take Kreis’ at its word and order something built for it, like the 18 oz Berkshire pork chop, charbroiled or breaded. And if a big beef dinner is wrong for the occasion altogether, this town has other answers; start with the dishes this city actually invented.

Booking a night that has to go right? Browse steak houses across the St. Louis metro on St Louis Near Me Directory, pull up the two menus you like most, and do the five-minute check above before you pick up the phone.

If you own the supper club, the chophouse or the corner bar with a strip on the chalkboard, your house rules and your Sunday special are exactly what diners are hunting for. A listing on St Louis Near Me Directory puts that menu in front of the people deciding where tonight’s dinner goes, and that is how a room gets more customers who already know what they want to order.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best steak house in St. Louis?

The best one is the one whose menu fits your night. For a big, old-school prime rib dinner, Kreis’ in Frontenac has been serving since 1948 and prints its grade, its aging and its doneness chart. For a smaller room with soup or salad and a side included in the steak price, Citizen Kane’s has served dinner in a Victorian home since 1993.

Where can I find the best cheap steak in St. Louis?

Look for a fixed-price night. Kreis’ Sunday night special is three courses for $55 per guest with a 12 oz Queen Cut of prime rib, dine-in only, and you must mention it when you order. Its $20 Kreis’ Steakburger with steak fries is the lowest-priced beef on that menu.

What makes a steak house a steakhouse?

Beef sits at the center of the menu and the kitchen is built around it, with steaks priced by cut and weight and the grade often printed beside them. The seafood, the sides and the sauces are arranged around the steak rather than beside it. Kreis’ even lists its prime rib under the heading “The Last Word in Prime Rib.”

What makes a steak house truly exceptional?

Consistency you would bet an anniversary on. The kitchen hits the temperature you asked for every visit, the server can name the grade and the aging without looking it up, and the house rules are written down where you can read them. A printed doneness chart, like the one at Kreis’, is a kitchen putting its standard on paper.

What is the proper etiquette at a steakhouse?

Order your steak the way you like it, and read the house rules first. Some rooms say no splitting entrees, and Kreis’ may add a 20% gratuity for parties of 8 or more with no separate checks. Agree on shared sides as a table. If a steak arrives wrong, say so at the first bite, not the last.

What is the dress code for a steak house?

Business casual covers most St. Louis steakhouses. Kreis’ asks for no athletic wear, sweatpants or cut-off shorts, shirts with sleeves for men, and hats off at the door. When you are unsure, call and ask; the host will tell you.

What is the difference between a steak house and a chop house?

Today the two words are used almost interchangeably on signs. A chophouse menu tends to lean harder on chops of lamb, veal and pork alongside the beef, the way Kreis’ lists double-boned Colorado lamb chops and a Berkshire pork chop next to its steaks.

Why are steak houses dark?

Low light, dark wood and deep booths make a long, expensive dinner feel private, and they flatter both the room and the plate. It is a convention, not a rule. Plenty of newer steakhouses are bright, and a steak at the bar usually comes under ordinary lights.

St Louis Near Me Directory Logo
About the Author: The St Louis Near Me Directory Team
Written by a dedicated team of St. Louis locals who live, work, and play right here in the St. Louis metro. Founder Lane Forman and team are committed to building the region’s most trusted directory by verifying listings and connecting local businesses with loyal customers across Missouri and Illinois.
Follow us:
Facebook LinkedIn X Pinterest YouTube Instagram TikTok Threads
St Louis Near Me Directory on Patch
Refuse to be invisible.
Does AI cite your expertise?
Run Your Free AI Audit
No credit card. No obligation.
Business idea? Does your town need it?
When you win, we all win.