Gioia's Hot Salami Is Fresh Sausage: How to Order at a St. Louis Deli
Revised October 28, 2026
What is the best deli in Saint Louis?
There is no single winner, because the metro runs several kinds of deli and each one wins a different errand. For cured meat by weight and olive salad, an Italian grocery on The Hill. For burek and smoked beef, a Bosnian market in south city. For a tray that feeds a party, a counter that takes catering calls. For a sandwich only this city makes, the hot salami above. Pick by errand, not by ranking.
Keep reading ↓“Just get it, you won’t be sorry.” That is not a review. That is the deli itself talking: Gioia’s on The Hill prints that line on its own menu, right next to the Hot Salami and Roast Beef, with one more piece of advice in quotes after it - try it on garlic cheese bread.
Stand on Macklind Avenue at a quarter to twelve and you understand why a sandwich shop would talk like that. The line runs back toward the door. The slicer hums. Garlic cheese bread comes out of the oven with the cheese still moving, and somebody ahead of you orders without even looking up at the board.
Here is the turn most visitors miss. The hot salami at Gioia’s is not the dry, hard salami in a grocery case. The menu calls it “Gioia’s fresh sausage, Sliced Fresh To Order,” and the shop’s own site signs off with two words: Since 1918. The menu lists it at two prices, $13.50 and $11. The counter on The Hill runs Monday through Saturday, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., and it is closed on Sunday - so the craving that hits after church waits until the next day. The number is 314-776-9410. Feeding a crowd? Gioia’s asks for 24 hour notice on all catering jobs and lists a full case that feeds 10 for $100. Ten people fed from one phone call, the day before.
That is the leverage point for this whole category in St. Louis. The word deli covers several different businesses here, and each one is brilliant at one thing. Walk into the right one for your errand and lunch is the best part of the day. Walk into the wrong one and you get a fine sandwich and the nagging sense you missed something.
What is the best deli in Saint Louis?
There is no single winner, because the metro runs several kinds of deli and each one wins a different errand. For cured meat by weight and olive salad, an Italian grocery on The Hill. For burek and smoked beef, a Bosnian market in south city. For a tray that feeds a party, a counter that takes catering calls. For a sandwich only this city makes, the hot salami above. Pick by errand, not by ranking.
Cured meat sliced to order and a jar of olive salad? Italian grocery. Corned beef stacked on rye? A Jewish-style sandwich house. Burek by the pan? A Bosnian market. A sandwich built while you fill the truck? The corner counter. A tray for eighteen people on Saturday? The grocery deli, with a phone number that answers.
The sandwiches St. Louis invented
The Gerber is the one people from here defend. It is a half section of Italian or French bread spread with garlic butter, topped with ham and Provel, sprinkled with paprika and toasted until the top blisters and the edges go crisp enough to scrape the roof of your mouth. It was first made at the family-owned Ruma’s Deli and named for their customer and next-door neighbor, Dick Gerber, who ran a tire store beside them. The Rumas liked what he built so much they put it on the menu in 1973.
Provel is the cheese that makes it taste like home to some people and like a mistake to others. It is a white processed cheese made from cheddar, Swiss and provolone, with a low melting point and a gooey, buttery bite. It does not string. It slumps.
The St. Paul sandwich is the other Missouri original, and you will not find it at a deli at all. It is an egg foo young patty with dill pickle slices, white onion, mayonnaise and lettuce on white bread, sold at Chinese American carryouts. Hot, soft, crunchy and sour in one bite, wrapped in paper that goes translucent before you reach the car.
What an Italian deli on The Hill does best
The bell over the door, the cold breath of the case on your hands, a wheel of cheese sweating on the counter under plastic. An Italian deli is a grocery first and a sandwich shop second. The counter exists to sell you a quarter pound of something sharp, fresh mozzarella in its own water, olive salad and bread with a crust that crackles when you squeeze it.
The neighborhood is built for it. The Hill’s own neighborhood history page says the Hill is home to more than 30 restaurants and four Italian grocery stores, plus bakeries and a gelato shop. You can park once and shop all of it on foot.
If one sandwich has to teach you the whole neighborhood, the Italian Trio on Gioia’s menu does it: mortadella, Genoa and hot salami on garlic cheese bread, garnished with pepperoncini, onions, and vinegar and oil. Soft, peppery, sharp and wet in the right way. Eat it standing up on the sidewalk with the paper peeled back, because it will not survive the drive home looking the way it did at the counter.
How to order: tell them what it is for. Salami for a sandwich gets sliced thin; salami for a board gets sliced thick enough to stand up. Ask for the ends if you are cooking with it.
What a Bosnian market with a counter does best
Smoke hits you first, then butter and onion from the pastry tray. That is a Bosnian market: smoked and air-dried beef, cevapi by weight, and pastry by the pan. The Bosnian community here grew up first in the “Little Bosnia” neighborhood of Bevo Mill and has since spread into suburbs such as Affton, Mehlville and Oakville. The markets followed the families.
A Bosnian market is a grocery with a counter in the back, not a restaurant with a shelf out front. Behind the glass, look for smoked beef, sausage, soft cheese, red pepper spread and trays of burek sold by the piece. The pastry case smells like butter and onion and it empties first.
How to order: point, then say the weight. If you have never had it, buy small and come back - nobody minds a beginner, and the person at the counter will usually tell you how to cook it.
Jewish-style delis are the third pillar: brisket cured and steamed into corned beef or pastrami, cut across the grain and stacked on rye with mustard. Jewish-style and certified kosher are not the same thing, so if kashrut matters to you, ask about certification instead of reading it off a menu. Corner-store counters feed trades crews and second shift fast. Grocery delis win on trays and salads by the pound. To check any counter’s inspection record inside the city, the City of St. Louis runs a food-service ratings search.
How do you order at a deli counter without holding up the line?
Say the weight, not the number of slices, and say the thickness. Those two habits are the whole difference between a smooth order and the sigh behind you. Take a number, decide before it is called, and lead with what the meat is for.
The vocabulary is short: shaved, thin, sandwich cut, thick. Shaved is for hot sandwiches where you want the meat to fold. Sandwich cut is the default. Thick is for cubing into salads. Ask for a sample slice before they run the whole order - it is a normal request - and order the meats before the cheese so the slicer is not cleaned twice.
Timing beats everything. Go before the noon crowd or after it, and on The Hill remember the clock: at Gioia’s, the doors on Macklind close at 4 p.m.
Wildly off-topic, but if the car gets towed while you wait for your number, here is what to do next - and where to find auto parts after.
How do you order a catering tray from a deli?
Call early and ask the shop’s own rule. The Gioia’s numbers above - 24 hour notice, a full case that feeds 10 for $100, a half case that feeds 5 for $50 - make a useful yardstick when another counter quotes you a price for the same headcount.
Ask four things when you call: what is on the tray, whether condiments come on the side, what the pickup window is, and whether they hold trays cold until you arrive. Order bread separately if the party runs long, because pre-built sandwiches go soft by the second hour. The same plan-ahead logic applies to tables, tents and chairs.
Why the same sandwich rings up differently across the river
Because Missouri and Illinois tax food on different rules, and a deli sits right on that line. In Missouri, the Department of Revenue says the state rate for qualifying food sales was reduced from 4.225% to 1.225%. The reduced rate does not apply to a business where food prepared for immediate consumption is more than 80% of its total gross receipts - which describes most standalone sandwich shops.
Illinois changed its own grocery rule. The Illinois Department of Revenue says that effective January 1, 2026, the state eliminated its one-percent sales tax on groceries, while local governments may adopt their own. Food prepared for immediate consumption was never in that grocery bucket. So on the east side, the cold-case sandwich and the counter-built one can be different tax animals.
What a deli counter actually makes money on
Not the pound of ham. Sliced meat by weight runs on a commodity price the shop does not set, and every counter loses some yield on the slicer, the heels and whatever does not move out of the case. The margin lives in the built sandwich, the house salads and the catering tray. That is why a good counter would rather you order by weight and by purpose: it keeps the line moving and the case fresh.
Pick two counters, not one. Browse delis across the St. Louis metro on St Louis Near Me Directory: one near work for the sandwich, one near home for the by-weight run.
If you run the counter with the line out the door at noon, the people searching for lunch near them should see you first. List your deli and get more customers walking in hungry.
Frequently asked questions
What is a must eat in St. Louis?
On the deli side of town, make it a hot salami sandwich on The Hill and a Gerber, the garlic-buttered ham and Provel sandwich first made at Ruma’s Deli. Add a burek from a Bosnian market in south city. Those three cover real local traditions instead of a tourist checklist.
What sandwich is St. Louis known for?
The Gerber: garlic-buttered Italian or French bread with ham and Provel, sprinkled with paprika and toasted open-faced. It went on the menu at Ruma’s Deli in 1973 and was named for a customer, Dick Gerber. The St. Paul sandwich, an egg foo young patty on white bread, is the other Missouri original, sold at Chinese American carryouts.
What is the average cost of a deli sandwich?
Treat any single number as a guess. For one real data point, Gioia’s lists its original Hot Salami at $13.50 and $11, its two menu prices. Meat weight, built-to-order versus cold case, and tax treatment move the price from there.
What’s a good side to order at a deli?
Whatever the case is turning over fastest, because sides are sold by the pound and freshness tracks volume. A vinegar slaw or pasta salad if the sandwich is rich, potato salad if it is not, a pickle spear either way. At an Italian grocery, olive salad doubles as a sandwich upgrade.
What is the unhealthiest lunch meat?
There is no single worst one, but the cured, salty options - salami, bologna, pepperoni - are the ones to keep for a treat. Read the sodium line on the label or ask the counter. Roast turkey or roast beef sliced fresh is the easy everyday swap.
What is the best deli in downtown St. Louis?
Downtown counters are built for office and courthouse traffic, so expect speed and a tight menu rather than a full grocery case. Judge them on turnover and hours. For a by-weight or catering run, the short drive to The Hill pays off.
Where can I find the best lunch in Saint Louis?
Match the counter to the hour you have. Forty minutes near an office park means a corner or grocery counter. Ninety minutes means The Hill or a south city market where you can shop and eat. Going before or after the noon rush gets you a better sandwich from a calmer counter almost anywhere.
