St Louis Near Me Directory
📍 Is your business already listed? Claim your free listing · badge, QR code & more.Claim it Free →
Home › Blog

Your Finished Basement Is Not Living Area to an Appraiser

Revised October 29, 2026

Your Finished Basement Is Not Living Area to an Appraiser
Quick answer

What is the point of getting a house appraised?

On a mortgage, the appraisal tells the lender whether the house is worth enough to back the loan. Federal Loan Estimate rules say the creditor may order an appraisal to determine the value of the property and may charge you for it, and you are entitled to a copy before closing. Outside a loan, you hire the appraiser for your own purpose, such as an estate, divorce or tax appeal.

Keep reading ↓

The laser measure clicks on the top step. The appraiser heads down the basement stairs, past the carpet and the drywall you paid for, the stairwell air cooler than the kitchen, sweeps the red dot across the far wall, taps the tablet, and moves on. You stand at the top of the stairs doing the math in your head. That room was supposed to be the fourth bedroom.

On the report, it won’t be. The Fannie Mae Selling Guide says a level counts as below-grade “if any portion of it is below-grade, regardless of the quality of its finish or the window area of any room,” and that “a walk-out partially below-grade area with finished rooms would not be included in the above-grade square footage or room count.” The finished basement still has value. It just lands on its own line, the Basement & Finished Rooms Below-Grade line, not in the living area at the top of the page. Finished is not the same as counted.

Here is the part that only works in the City of St. Louis, and you can check it tonight from the couch. The City Building Division lists “the conversion of basement or below-grade space to living quarters” as work that requires a building permit. And the City Assessor’s Address & Property Search covers any property in the City of St. Louis: type in the address or parcel ID, pay nothing, and the record shows Building Permit Records next to the sale information and tax history. Questions about a permit go to the Building Division Permit Section at (314) 622-3313. If the house sits out in St. Louis County instead, this City search is the wrong door; ask the seller for the permit paperwork directly.

So look the house up before the appraiser’s car is in the driveway. Selling? If the basement finish shows up in the permit records, print that page and put it in a folder on the kitchen counter with the year the roof went on. If it doesn’t, you want to know that now, not when a buyer’s agent asks. Buying? Look up the address the night the contract is signed. A finished basement with no permit record on a City house is a question for the seller, in writing, before appraisal day.

Then the day itself. Unlock the attic hatch, crawlspace, furnace room, electrical panel and every bedroom; a locked door can mean a second trip. Never tell the appraiser the number you need. Hand over facts instead: permit dates, what the remodel included, a nearby sale you think compares. And if a loan is involved, ask your lender when you will see the report, because under 12 CFR 1002.14 the lender must give you a copy of the appraisal no later than three business days before closing.

What is the point of getting a house appraised?

The appraiser’s car pulls away and you realize nobody asked what you think the house is worth. That is by design. When you borrow, the appraisal answers the lender’s question, not yours: is this house worth enough to back the loan? The Loan Estimate rule spells it out in the statement lenders must give you: “The creditor may order an appraisal to determine the value of the property” and may charge you for it. You pay for a report that protects someone else’s money. That is the quiet part, and it is worth hearing out loud before the visit.

You still get to read it. Under the Equal Credit Opportunity Act rule at 12 CFR 1002.14, a creditor must provide a copy of each appraisal or other written valuation “promptly upon completion, or three business days prior to consummation of the transaction” on a first-lien home loan, whichever is earlier. Sit down with it at the kitchen table, not at the closing table.

Outside of a loan, the purpose flips. Divorce, an estate, a tax appeal, pricing a house before you list it: in those, you hire the appraiser, you are the client, and the report answers your question. In an estate, the furniture needs its own opinion too; that is a job for antique dealers, not the appraiser of the house.

What the appraiser actually looks at, and why your basement lands on its own line

Three things: your house, the recent sales near it, and the market around both. They measure, sketch the floor plan, note condition, quality, age and room count, then adjust nearby sales up or down for each difference until a value comes out the other side. Fannie Mae requires them to follow the ANSI Z765-2021 measuring standard for above- and below-grade square footage, finished and unfinished, on single-family homes, and to report below-grade areas separately, with adjustments on the Basement & Finished Rooms Below-Grade line of the sales comparison grid.

That standard is why the number on the report may not match the number on the listing or the assessor’s card. Different method, different total. If the gap is big, it is worth asking which rooms were counted where, and the answer is usually on the sketch page.

An appraisal is not a home inspection. The appraiser forms an opinion of value and notes conditions that affect it. Nobody is running the furnace through a cycle or putting a camera down the sewer lateral. That is a separate hire, and a lot sits outside a standard inspection too, which is the subject of home inspections in St. Louis and what they miss.

An appraiser measuring the exterior of a brick house with a laser distance tool in a St. Louis neighborhood

Who orders it, and why you cannot pick the appraiser

On a mortgage, the lender may order the appraisal and charge you for it. The appraiser’s opinion is supposed to be independent, and federal valuation rules at 12 CFR 1026.42 protect that: no covered person - the lender, or anyone providing settlement services - may try to make the value rest on anything other than the appraiser’s independent judgment “through coercion, extortion, inducement, bribery, or intimidation.” The rule is written for the people in the deal, but the lesson for a homeowner is the same: give facts, not a target.

The fee shows up on your Loan Estimate under the subheading “Services You Cannot Shop For,” and that heading is literal. For the rest of that page - title, settlement, transfer taxes and prepaids - see what closing costs actually cost in St. Louis. This post stays on the appraisal line.

The same federal rule also covers the person doing the work. The creditor and its agents must pay a fee appraiser a rate that is customary and reasonable for comparable appraisal services in the geographic market. The fee you pay is not always the fee the appraiser keeps, which comes up again in the FAQ below.

Unrelated, and we know it - once the number holds, the boxes start: what a move costs in St. Louis.

When the number comes in low

The phone call is short and the silence after it is long. The lender lends against the appraised value, not your contract price, so a low number opens a gap somebody has to cover. The real moves: renegotiate the price, split the difference, bring cash, ask the lender to send the appraiser specific corrections, or walk away if your contract gives you that right.

Corrections run on facts. A sale near you that closed and was not used. A bedroom count that is wrong. Square footage that does not match the sketch. A condition rating that ignores the kitchen you permitted and paid for. What does not move it: needing the number to be higher.

Sellers have levers too: hold the price and let the buyer bring cash, meet in the middle, accept the lower number, or relist. Read your contract for the appraisal deadline and put it on the fridge.

How to check that an appraiser is licensed in Missouri

It takes a minute. Missouri appraisal licenses and certificates are issued by the Missouri Real Estate Appraisers Commission, and its page on pr.mo.gov links to the state’s licensee search. The commission’s office in Jefferson City answers at 573.751.0038. Its application list covers trainee, certified residential, certified general and state license applicants.

The license is not a formality. Under section 339.501 RSMo, beginning July 1, 1999, it became unlawful for anyone in Missouri to act as a real estate appraiser without first obtaining a license or certificate from the commission. The same law says it shall not be construed to require a license for a licensed real estate broker or salesperson who prepares a comparative market analysis or a broker price opinion. So the free pricing opinion your agent emails over is useful, and legally it is not an appraisal.

If the real question is pricing strategy rather than value, that is advice work, covered in what a real estate consultant does and what it costs.

A side note for owners who stay: the City tax hearing

Not selling? The same appraisal has a second life. In the City of St. Louis, a relative with a real estate license can sit beside you at a Board of Equalization hearing, but the Assessor’s own page says an agent “may not present an opinion of value unless they are licensed or certified as an appraiser.” You may give your own opinion of value. The board sits in Room 120 of City Hall, wants six copies of anything you want considered, and appeals are due by the second Monday in July.

Every other year the assessor puts a new value on your house, and if it reads high, the fight is at the Board of Equalization. The city lists common evidence as copies of sale contracts, information on comparable properties, income and expense statements and descriptive photographs. A licensed appraisal pulls the comparable sales, the measurements and the photos into one signed document, which is exactly the shape of evidence the board asks for.

Then the hearing itself: the board president asking whether you have documentation, the assessor or staff present with the right to present evidence of their own. That last part matters. You are not arguing with a form; there is someone across the room defending the number. Bring the six copies, signature page on top.

The assessed number itself is not market value, by design. Missouri assesses residential property at nineteen percent of true value under section 137.115 RSMo, and new values are set as of January first of each odd-numbered year. The statute also says that before the assessor raises a home’s value more than fifteen percent since the last assessment, excluding new construction or improvements, the assessor shall conduct a physical inspection. If your notice jumped and nobody came by, that is a question worth asking. Here is how to appeal your property assessment in St. Louis County.

Need a value nobody is going to argue with? Browse real estate appraisers across the St. Louis metro on St Louis Near Me Directory, check the license on the state site, then call two and ask each for the fee and the turn time in writing for your purpose - estate, divorce, tax appeal or pre-listing.

If you’re the certified residential appraiser people call when the number has to hold up at a hearing, the private work starts with a local search. See how a Gold listing helps you get more customers, or list your practice.

Frequently asked questions

What is the typical cost of an appraisal in Missouri?

I could not find a Missouri agency that publishes an average fee, so treat any single number you see online with care. On a mortgage, your fee is itemized on the Loan Estimate under “Services You Cannot Shop For.” For a private appraisal, call two licensed appraisers and get written quotes; acreage, an unusual floor plan or a rush job raises the price.

What should I do before an appraiser comes to my house?

Open everything and gather paper. Unlock the attic hatch, crawlspace, furnace room, electrical panel and every bedroom. Put permits for the basement finish and any remodel in one folder, with the roof’s age. Skip the deep clean; access matters more than housekeeping. A locked room can mean a second trip.

What not to say to an appraiser?

Do not name the number you need. Federal valuation rules at 12 CFR 1026.42 bar the lender and settlement service providers from trying to steer the value away from the appraiser’s independent judgment through coercion, inducement or intimidation, and a homeowner gains nothing by trying either. Facts are welcome: permit dates, what the remodel included, a nearby sale you believe is comparable. A target price is not a fact.

What devalues a home appraisal?

Deferred maintenance, functional problems and square footage that does not count where you expected. Fannie Mae treats any level with a portion below grade as below-grade, regardless of finish, so a finished walkout is adjusted on its own line rather than counted as above-grade living area. Wrong facts on the report can hurt too, so read your copy.

What are the red flags for home appraisals?

Factual errors first: wrong square footage, a wrong bedroom or bathroom count, a condition rating that ignores documented work, comparable sales from too far away, or a recent sale on your street that was never considered. Those are the points to send back through your lender, in writing, with proof.

Is there a downside to getting your house appraised?

You pay up front, and the fee does not come back if you dislike the result. On a purchase, a value under the contract price opens a gap the lender will not cover. On a refinance, a low value can change the loan terms you were counting on. For a tax appeal or an estate, the downside is smaller: you hired the appraiser and you choose whether to use the report.

Is there a way to get a free appraisal?

Not a real one. A licensed agent’s comparative market analysis is often free, and section 339.501 RSMo does not require an appraiser license for a broker or salesperson who prepares one, because it is not an appraisal. At a City of St. Louis Board of Equalization hearing you may give your own opinion of value at no cost, but an agent speaking for you must be a licensed or certified appraiser to offer one.

How much money does an appraiser make per appraisal?

Often less than you paid, when a management company sits between the lender and the appraiser and keeps a share. I could not find a published figure for the split. What federal rules do require, under 12 CFR 1026.42, is that the creditor and its agents pay the fee appraiser a rate that is customary and reasonable for comparable appraisal services in the geographic market.

St Louis Near Me Directory Logo
About the Author: The St Louis Near Me Directory Team
Written by a dedicated team of St. Louis locals who live, work, and play right here in the St. Louis metro. Founder Lane Forman and team are committed to building the region’s most trusted directory by verifying listings and connecting local businesses with loyal customers across Missouri and Illinois.
Follow us:
Facebook LinkedIn X Pinterest YouTube Instagram TikTok Threads
St Louis Near Me Directory on Patch
Refuse to be invisible.
Does AI cite your expertise?
Run Your Free AI Audit
No credit card. No obligation.
Business idea? Does your town need it?
When you win, we all win.